Manchester Metropolitan University

Department Psychology ands Speech Pathology

BSc Psychology; BSc Psychology Combined Honours; MSc Modular; Short Course

Psychology, Culture and Identity

The course this year will be taught by Carolyn Kagan (Paper Leader), Kath Knowles, Rebecca Lawthom, Elliot Cohen and Paul Duckett. We will each be responsible for one or more of the integrated topics within the course.

The learning outcomes are that by the end of the course you will:

    1. Be able to examine the contribution of psychological concepts and techniques to the understanding of cultural diversity and social identity;
    2. Be able to demonstrate a knowledge of the development of cultural influences on identity formation;
    3. Be able to apply knowledge about psychological aspects of culture and identity to contemporary cultural phenomena;
    4. Become more aware about personal values and self-concept

 

Throughout the term, we will use a variety of teaching techniques. These may include experiential techniques, the use of different media, lectures and group discussion. Some sessions may include visiting speakers. Throughout the course, we will not be teaching psychology, culture and identity as an external body of knowledge. Instead, we will be grounding the topics in our own experiences and linking these, and those of others, to psychological literature. We will all need to be prepared to contribute actively to the sessions, in a non-judgemental atmosphere.

The teaching and learning schedule is as follows:

Date

Staff

Topic

1.10

All

Introduction to the course and to each other

8.10

CK

Poverty and social exclusion

15.10

PD

Personal learning styles, values and beliefs.

22.10

EC

Problems with Psychological Culture

29.10

KK

Power and oppression

5.11

Assignment

Week

No session. Consultation on assignments

12.11

KK

Health, professionals, policy and practice

19.11

RL

Body, identity, disability and gender

26.11

PD

Limitations of Western psychology; Reflexivity and the ‘self’

3.12

CK

Identity fragmentation and strategies for integration.

10.12

Assignment

No session. Consultation on assignments

     

Why Do the Course?

There may be a number of reasons why you may be interested in this course. You may be interested in exploring some of the ways psychology helps or hinders us from understanding diverse social experience, and the implications of this for personal and social lives. You may be interested in the limitations of the discipline of psychology for understanding social phenomena that affect us all and that influence legislation and social policy. You may be interested in developing a psychological understanding of social issues and contemporary events.

Sessions

Poverty and social exclusion. Carolyn Kagan

Poverty and social exclusion are life defining experiences, embedded within social policies and practices. Social Exclusion is a relatively new concept that is being incorporated into the social worlds of governments and citizens, although the fact of social exclusion has always existed. This session will explore the extent to which poverty and social exclusion are linked socially, culturally and psychologically and how the discipline of psychology helps us understand the phenomena and how they may be reduced.

Indicative reading

Atd Fourth World. Participation Works. (from ATD Fourth World

48, Addington Square, London SE 5 7LB)

Cohen, A. (ed) (1982) Belonging : identity and social organisation in British rural cultures Manchester University Press

Gilchrist,R. and Jeffs, T (2000) Settlements, social change and

community action - Good Neighbours. Jessica Kingsley

Hopper,P. ( 2001) Rebuilding Communities in an age of individualism

Ashgate

Kagan, C., Lawthom R., Knowles, K. and Burton, M. (2000) Community activism, participation and social capital on a peripheral housing estate Manchester, IOD Research Group (access www.compsy.org.uk for a copy).

Lister, R (1998) From equality to social inclusion: New Labour and the welfare state Critical Social Policy 18 (2) 215-226

McDonald, R (ed) (1997) Youth, The ‘Underclass and Social Exclusion London, Routledge

Millar, B. (1995) Heaviness in the Air Health Services Journal 25 May p.16

Parker I and Spears R (Eds) (1996) Psychology and Society London Pluto Press (Ch By M. Burton and C. Kagan 'Rethinking Empowerment')

Preece, J. and Houghton, A-M (2000) Nurturing social capital in

excluded communities Ashgate

Room, G. (1996) Beyond the Threshold: The Measurement and Analysis of Social Exclusion Bristol, Policy Press

Spear, R., Defourny, J. Favreau, L., Laville, J-L (eds) 2001 Tackling

social exclusion in Europe. Ashgate 0 7546 1383 6

and any report from the Social Exclusion Unit or other Government Depts (e.g. recent Home Office report on Social Cohesion

 

 

Personal learning styles, values and beliefs. Paul Duckett

Our values and beliefs, as well as our personal learning styles influences both how we seek out opportunities and how we respond to them. Throughout our lives we are subject to lots of influences which contribute to our self-concepts and interests in life. These in turn influence who we spend time with and what we spend our time doing.

In this session we will draw on personal experiences to explore how and why we use our time as we do; how we respond individually to different experiences and how individual experiences combine at institutional and societal levels.

Indicative reading

Leonard, P. (1978) Ideology and Personality London, Macmillan

Birkitt, I (1992) Social Selves London, Sage

Birkitt, I (1999) Bodies of Thought: Embodiment, identity and modernity London, Sage

Skevington, S. and Baker, D. (1989) Social Identity of Women London, Sage

Saraga, E. (1998) Embodying the social: Social constructions of difference London, Open University Press

Shakespeare, T. (2000) Help London, Venture Press

Kolb, D.A. (1985) Experiential Learning : experience as the source of learning and development Englewood Cliffs NJ, Prentice Hall

Revans, R. (1982) The Origins and Growth of Action Learning Chartwell-Bratt

Revans, R. (1998) ABC of action learning [3rd ed.]. - London : Lemos & Crane,

Rokeach, (1968) - Beliefs, attitudes and values : a theory of organization and change London : Jossey-Bass,

Housley, W. and Hester, S (2001) Language Interaction and National

Identity Ashgate

 

Psychology of the East. Elliöt Cohen.

Summary:To compare and contrast Western and Eastern approaches to

Psychology.

'Who am I?' although a universal question, has been approached (and

continues to be approached) in radically different ways. This topic

shall explore Hindu, Buddhist and Taoist forms of (what is recognised today as being) Psychology, as well as some key Kabbalistic concepts. The East

meets West dialogue shall also be explored; how Eastern thought helped to

shape and influence many philosophical/psychological theories post 1960s.

The session will involve lecture, group discussion and traditional

Buddhist meditation.

Outcomes: To overcome ethnocentric notions about Psychology being purely

Western or even purely scientific.

Indicative reading

Buddha (500 BCE) 'The Dhammapada'

Mark Epstein (1996) 'Thoughts Without a Thinker: Psychotherapy from a

Buddhist Perspective', Basic Books:US

Lao Tzu (300 BCE) 'Tao Te Ching'

Jean-Francois Revel, Matthieu Ricard (1999) 'The Philosopher and the

Monk' HarperCollins, UK.

Alan Watts, (1996), 'The Tao of Philosophy', Eden Grove Editions:US

Power and oppression. Kath Knowles

This session will explore the experience of mental illness in our community today and how cultural issues affect the personal identity of people who suffer from a mental illness. The session will start by exploring a psychological model of personal identity, its features and its functions, especially in regard to psychological health. Then cultural issues will be examined with special reference to organisational culture, professional culture and resistance to change as reflected in the mental health service in the UK. The position of the users of the mental health services will be considered in relation to notions of power and oppression.

Health, professionals, policy and practice. Kath Knowles

In this session we will examine current policy and practice regarding the participation of service users in the development and delivery of mental health services and the implications for personal identity. Finally we will ask what is the role of psychology in this area and what are the implications and possibilities for change.

A range of teaching/learning methods will be used for these sessions. These will include the viewing of excerpts from a video of the case of one person’s experiences as he moves from his home in the community to the psychiatric hospital and back to his home again. The will be some tutor input on theoretical and conceptual issues. There will also be some group discussions and exercises.

Indicative reading (for Kath’s 2 sessions):

Audit Commission, 1994, Finding a place, HMSO, London

Barham, P and Hayward R, 1995, Relocating madness, Free Association Books. London

Barnes M and Bowl R, 2001, Taking over the asylum: Empowerment and mental health, Palgrave, Basingstoke, Hants

Bond MH, 1998, Working at the interface of cultures, Routledge, London

Chmiel N (ed), 2000, Introduction to work and organisational psychology: A European perspective, Blackwell Publishers Ltd, Oxford

Clegg, S, 1979, The theory of power and organisation,

Coleman R, 1998, The politics of the madhouse, Handsell Publishing, Runcorn, Cheshire

Crisp AH, Gelder MG, Rix S, Meltzer HJ and Rowlands OJ, 2000, Stigmatisation of people with mental illness, BJ Psychiatry, 177, 4-7

Fernando S, 1988, Race and culture in psychiatry, Croom Helm Ltd, Beckenham, Kent

French JRP and Raven BH, 1959, The bases of social power. In D Cartwright (ed), Studies in social power, Ann Arbor, Michigan, Institute for Social Research

Handy C, 1993, Understanding organisations, Penguin, London

Johnson DW, 1993, Reaching out: Interpersonal effectiveness and self-actualization, (5th Ed), Allyn and Bacon, London etc

Myers F and Macdonald C, 1996, Power to the people? Involving users and careers in needs assessment and care planning – views from the practitioners, Health and social care in the community, 4(2), 86-95

Pilgrim D and Rogers A, 1993, A sociology of mental health and illness, Open University Press

Sayce L, 2000, From psychiatric patient to citizen: Overcoming discrimination and social exclusion, McMillan Press Ltd, London

Representations of gender and disability. Rebecca Lawthom

‘Representation is not a luxury: it is an integral part of a process concerned with access, empowerment, collective action and rights. It is a political agenda’ (Langley’s foreword in Hevey, 1992)

Our sense of who we are: woman, man, heterosexual, gay, disabled, black, white come not only from our embodiment (having a body, skin, gender to define us) but also from the way other perceive us. The images and representations we are subject to position us in certain ways. These positionings can influence self-esteem, having both positive and negative implications in terms of roles ascribed. Roles we occupy in society in private arenas (the family) and more public spaces (the labour market) are shaped by identity formation and representations held by others (and ourselves). In this session we will consider the way in which representations of groupings of people, in particular female disabled identities, can impact upon life experiences and opportunities.

Indicative reading

Atkinson, D., & Williams, F. (Ed.). (1990). 'Know me as I am': An

Anthology of Prose, Poetry and Art by People with Learning

difficulties. Kent: Hodder & Stoughton in association with the Open

University and MENCAP.

Hevey, D. (1992) The Creatures that time forgot: Photography and Disability Imagery. London:Routledge.

Oliver, M. (1996). Understanding Disability: From Theory to Practice. London: Macmillan.

Morris, J. (1991) Pride against prejudice. London: The Women’s Press.

Morris, J. (Ed.). (1996). Encounters with Strangers: Feminism and Disability. London: The Women's Press.

Thomas, C. (1999) Female forms: Experiencing and understanding disability. Buckingham: OUP.

Journals

Feminism and Psychology

Disability & Society .

In terms of Websites there are many and these link into other sites and related journals.

codi.buffalo.edu - cornucopia of disability information

leeds.ac.uk/dru/dru.htm - Disability Research Unit at Leeds University

disabilitynet.co.uk/groups/gmcdp/index.html - superb site of Greater Manchester Coalition of Disabled People. Local and radical!

cpeoplefirst.demon.co.uk - Carlisle People First, a nationally regarded self-advocacy group of people with learning difficulties.

 

Limitations of Western psychology; Reflexivity and the ‘self’. Paul Duckett

In this session we will explore the notion of self via social identity theory as well as concepts such as personal and social agency and the sources of personal belief and value systems. The limitations of Western psychology will be a central element throughout.

This workshop will be a combination of input and experiential activity.

Indicative reading

Birkitt I (1992) Social Selves. Sage

Breakwell G (ed) (1992) Social Psychology of Identity and the Self. Academic Press

Burr V (1995)An Introduction to Social Constructionism. Routledge

Gergen K (1999) Introduction to Social Constructionism. Sage

Harre R (1998) The Singular Self. Sage

Michael M (1996) Constructing Identities. Sage

Rowan J (1988) Ordinary Ecstasy: Humanistic Psychology in Action. Routledge

Shotter J & Gergen K (eds) (1989) Texts of Identity. Sage

Stevens R (ed) (1996) Understanding the Self. Sage

Wilkinson S (ed) (1996) Feminist Social Psychologies Open University Press

Identity fragmentation and strategies for integration. Carolyn Kagan

All sorts of life experiences can lead to identity fragmentation. This session will explore ways of understanding fractured identity and the strategies people use to maintain identity. We will look at the role of social institutions in helping identity maintenance or not (e.g. prisons, hospitals, families, media etc.) Links will be made with personal experience and life course development, and social development.

Indicative reading

Ager, A 1999 Refugees: Perspectives on the experience of forced migration Cassell

Breakwell, G. (1996) Changing European identities : social psychological analyses of social change. Butterworth-Heinemann,

Breakwell, G (ed) (1992) Social psychology of identity and the self concept Academic Press

Breakwell, Glynis M.(1986) Coping with threatened identities. Methuen, 1986.

Breakwell, G. (ed) (1983) Threatened identities Wiley

Campbell, B, (1993) Goliath : Britain's dangerous places Methuen

Chambers, R. 1997 Whose reality Counts? Intermediate Technology

Cohen, A.P (1986) Symbolising boundaries : identity and diversity in British cultures Manchester University Press

Goffman, E (1968) - Stigma : notes on the management of spoiled identity. - Penguin,

Holdstock, T.L. (2000) Re-examining Psychology. Critical Perspectives and African Insights. London Routledge

J. Langer (ed) (1997) The Bend in the road : refugees writing - Nottingham : Five Leaves Publications

Minority Rights Group, (1998) Forging new identities : young refugees and minority students tell their stories London :.

Owusu-Bempah, K and Howitt, D (2000) Psychology: Beyond Western perspectives Leceister, BPS Books

Saraga, E. (1998) Embodying the social: Social constructions of difference Open University Press

Sharratt, S. (1999) Assault

 

Assessment (Undergraduate)

We have moved from Exam and Assessed Coursework to assessment by Assessed Coursework only.

There are two elements to the assessed coursework.

  1. Critical Analysis of a learning session
  2. Essay

(i) Critical analysis of a learning session

This is a portfolio assessment in which you record your impressions of any of the learning sessions, focusing on both the content and the teaching and learning process.

You should hand in a completed session form for at least 7 of the 10 learning sessions. See Appendix I for a sample form.

For ONE of these topics, expand your analysis to be a 1500 word report of the session, analysed with reference to relevant psychological literature.

Assessment Criteria

In addition to the general marking criteria for undergraduate assignments, we will use the following criteria for assessing the report.

    1. Critical use of relevant psychological literature, linked coherently to the particular session.
    2. Application of insights gained from the session to identity and cultural diversity
    3. Insight into learning content and process demonstrated
    4. Explicit analysis of the influence of and on personal identity within the session and/or the literature used.
    5. Analysis of cultural influences within the session and/or within the literature used

Appendix II shows the marking form to be used for the assignment.

 

(ii) Essay

Choose ONE. 2500 words

General Issues:

You must discuss your ideas with a tutor before doing a lot of work oin this assignment (the tutor responsible for each assignment is indicated below). Discuss your ideas with colleagues on the course too – but remember this is not a joint assignment.

Take care to structure your work (see advice under each assignment). You must make appropriate reference to the literature, critically where possible. In all assignments you will need to go beyond description and opinion. However insightful, description will not lead to a good mark. Good grades will be achieved by choosing an argument and pursuing it with the support of literature. Whilst we encourage the use of literature from outside psychology, you must anchor this in the use and limitations of psychological literature. So, wherever possible, appraise the psychological literature with reference to its adequacy in either helping to understand the phenomena under discussion or in constituting an acceptable body of knowledge. Credit will be given for critical thought.

Assignments that focus on only psychological knowledge and make no attempt to ground the discussion in some personal or cultural phenomena will not get good marks.

Use of self

It is appropriate in these assignments to write at least some of the work in the first person, but don’t forget to back up your views with additional support material where possible. In some assignments it will be quite appropriate to reflect upon how the material discussed has affected you, and we encourage the inclusion of a reflexive component.

References

You MUST reference your material according to academic conventions in psychology. This means using the Harvard referencing style. In the text include names and dates only, and in the reference list, list all references cited in alphabetical order, whether they are primary or secondary references.

If in doubt about preparing your assignments, ASK.

1. Fiction Assignment. Tutor: Elliot Cohen

Take a piece of fiction that includes biographical or autobiographical material and explore the way in which it weaves together themes of psychology, culture and identity.

You should structure your essay so that it includes the following sections: an opening paragraph setting out what the key psychological, cultural and identity issues are that you intend to focus upon in the text; an account of the theoretical resources (which may be from inside or outside psychology) that you will be drawing on to make sense of the text; a description of the text and your analysis of it (and here you may choose to provide a brief description which is followed by the analysis or provide an analytic account of the text which embeds the description within the analytic categories you have chosen); and a conclusion which draws together what this text and this analysis has shown us about psychology, culture and identity.

Criteria for evaluating this piece of work, and for obtaining good marks for this assignment, will include: clear structure, rationale, presentation and evaluation of the material; and creative, critical, innovative use of and reflections upon the material.

Indicative reading

Ridgway, J. and Benjamin, M. (1987) Psychological theories and science fictions. Leicester: British Psychological Society.

Potter, J., Stringer, P. and Wetherell, M. (1984) Social Texts and Context: Literature and social psychology. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.

Shotter, J. and Gergen, K. J. (eds) (1989) Texts of Identity. London: Sage.

 

 

2. Autobiographical account of identity formation. Tutor: Carolyn Kagan

Take any aspect of your own experience and discuss it in terms psychology, culture and identity.

The way you structure your assignment is up to you, but you must state in an opening paragraph how you have structured the essay. Following the introductory paragraph, you could talk about your personal experiences and then discuss relevant literature; or you could discuss relevant literature and then illustrate with reference to your personal experiences; or you could discuss the two simultaneously. You should end the essay with a concluding paragraph which sums up the main points you have made and your conclusions about how your experience informs psychology, culture and identity, and vice versa.

You may write in the first person (’I’) throughout the essay.

Criteria for evaluating this piece of work, and for obtaining good marks for this assignment, will include: clear structure, thoughtful linking of literature with life experience, presentation and evaluation of the material; and creative, critical, innovative reflections upon the material.

Indicative reading

Birkitt, I (1992) Social Selves London, Sage

Breakwell, G. (ed) (1992) Social psychology of identity and the self Academic Press

Campbell, J. (1996) Disability politics : understanding our past, changing our future Routledge,

Jackson, David, (1990)-. - Unmasking masculinity : a critical autobiography. - Unwin Hyman,

Mascuch, M. (1997) - Origins of the individualist self : autobiography and self-identity in England. - Cambridge : Polity Press

Goffman, E. (1972) Interaction ritual : essays on face - to - face behaviour. Penguin

Heron, L. (1985) Truth, Dare or Promise: Girls growing up in the fifties Virago

Osborne, S (1985) - The other side of me : black self identity. - Bristol : Campaign Against Racism in Education

Rogers, C. (1961) On Becoming a Person Constable

3. Television Programme Or Film. Tutor: Paul Duckett

You have two choices:

A. Choose a character from a television programme or film and critically explore aspects of their biography in terms of your perceptions of how their culture and identity processes have contributed to their current character.

OR

B. Choose a complete television programme or film. Critically explore how an issue or issues, apparent in the programme/film contribute to and/or challenge Western notions of psychology.

This assessed course work requires you to trace back aspects of culture and identity evident in your identified character/programme/film, to relevant psychological theories. Which theories are most useful in informing your understanding and very importantly which theories challenge your understanding. Where are the gaps in what psychology offers? In what ways does psychology help or hinder our understanding?

How to Manage the Task

Marking Criteria

Indicative reading

Burr V (1995) An Introduction to Social Constructionism. Routledge

Gergen, K (1999) Introduction to Social Constructionism. Sage

Harre, R (1998) The Singular Self. Sage

Michael, M (1996) Constructing Identities. Sage

Potter, J, Stringer P & Wetherell, M (1984) Social Texts and Context: Literature and Social Psychology. Routledge

Sapsford, R (ed)(1996) Issues in Social Psychology. The Open University

Stevens, R (ed) (1996) Understanding the Self. Sage

 

 

4. Exploring representations in a chosen domain. Tutor: Rebecca Lawthom

Using a number of visual representations (in a chosen arena) explore the relationships between what is presented and theories of psychology, culture and identity.

Choose an arena in which you are interested. It is quite acceptable to choose disability (outlined in the session) or you may wish to focus on other representations, such as sexuality, race, gender etc. Alternatively, you may wish to encompass a couple of areas such as gender and sexuality, race and disability. The aims of this course work are:

You can structure the assignment around the visual representations chosen. Firstly, choose some images to focus on. It is easier to do this is visual images are chosen, however, you can use other media, such as newspaper articles, web pages etc. Select around 5 or 6 images you wish to focus on. You now need to ‘read’ the images; in other words analyse the meanings of the images presented. What is presented or given off by the image, what is assumed or absent from the image? Representations are often constructed in terms of dualities – disabled/able bodied; male/female; gay/straight and white/black. Representations are therefore ‘relational’ – they can only be understood in relation to an implied ‘norm’. Present an analysis of the images, providing a theoretical context for your particular reading. What impact might these images have upon identity formation, identity across diverse cultures and theories of identity development? How does a representations which exists in the media interact with the way that people live their lives. The analysis undertaken will depend upon your interpretation of the images and thus reflexivity and transparency are important issues. Where do you stand in this analysis – in relation to the images provided?

The structure you adopt can be flexible but remember to weave into the analysis, some theoretical ideas. You could start with theory, then move onto images or vice versa OR talk about images and theory simultaneously.

Marking criteria:

An in-depth analysis of a small sample of material, demonstrating clear interpretation of the images chosen.

An understanding of the meanings associations and underlying themes conveyed in the material.

Thoughtful linking of the images and theory used.

An explicit recognition of reflexivity and transparency.

References

These are more closely associated with disability and/or feminism. Come and see me for pointers regarding other literature if you wish to focus on another domain.

Hevey, D. (1992) The Creatures that time forgot: Photography and Disability Imagery. London:Routledge.

Morris, J. (Ed.). (1996). Encounters with Strangers: Feminism and Disability. London: The Women's Press.

Thomas, C. (1999) Female forms: Experiencing and understanding disability. Buckingham: OUP.

5. Issues in psychology, culture and identity from the point of view of ….. (stakeholder). Tutor: Kath Knowles

 

The assignment for this component of the course will be an essay of not more than 2000 words based on an interview with a representative of a stakeholder group in the mental health services. Service providers (GPs, psychiatrists, clinical psychologists, community mental health nurses, psychiatric social workers, ward staff working in psychiatric units, etc), voluntary and statutory agencies (MIND, Making Space, National Schizophrenia Fellowship, Community Health Councils, etc) are all stakeholder groups. So of course are the users and ex users of the mental health services but because these are considered to be a vulnerable group, there are important ethical considerations in working with these persons. Students who are considering basing their essays on interviews with a user of ex user of the mental health services must consult me first for ethical clearance. Student should make their own arrangements for contacting, setting up the interview and interviewing a suitable stakeholder group member.

Guidelines

The interview should be audiotaped. It is not necessary to submit a transcript of the interview but the audiotape must be submitted with the essay.

The essay should be structured in three sections:

Introduction (around 500 words) - this should demonstrate understanding of literature in the area of psychology, culture and identity. The content of the literature review may vary depending on the stakeholder you interview but it should include the important theoretical and social issues as well as the more pragmatic bases for the development of mental health services planning and delivery (eg, theoretical models of organisational and professional cultures of psychiatry, knowledge of the social/political context mental health services, challenges to identity and the role of psychology in this arena. etc.)

Interview (around 1000 words) - this should be the thematic analysis of the interview you have conducted. Here you should demonstrate your ability to 'tease out' from the interview data any issues that link to the literature reviewed in the previous section, and any new ('emergent') issues.

Discussion (around 500 words) - here we will be looking at how well you have discussed and linked the issues from the interview to the literature that you presented in the introduction: how the issues may be interrelated; the nature of any tensions or conflictual areas; what possibilities/implications there are for change, etc. Your discussion should also be reflexive, ie, it should take into account the reactive effects of the interview situation, your personal position as interviewer, etc.

 

 

Assessment (Postgraduate)

EITHER a) One assignment from the list of set essays above OR b) Construction of a proposal for psychological research project in contemporary Britain that endeavours to be free from cultural bias OR c) an alternative title negotiated in advance with a tutor (2,500 words, worth 75%)

PLUS

Critical reflexive analysis of this assignment (1,500 words, worth 25%)

See above notes for discussion of how to go about the set essay components.

Criteria

Your work will be graded according to the extent to which you have shown:

 

 

 

 

Appendix I

Critical analysis of learning session record form

Topic:

Date/Tutor:

 

Teaching/learning methods:

 

 

 

 

 

My experience of the session:

Content

 

 

Process

 

 

 

 

 

Summary of how these issues might apply to aspects of my life or the life of others:

 

 

 

 

 

Limitations of psychological knowledge informing this issue.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Other comments:

 

 

 

 

 

 

Appendix II

Critical Analysis of learning session feedback and marking form.

 

75+……………………..

 

……………………….40-

 

 

Comprehensive, critical use of relevant psychological literature, linked coherently to the particular session.

75+ 68 65 63 58 55 53 48 45 43 38-

 

 

 

 

 

 

Little relevant psychological literature and weak incoherent link to session

Application of insights gained from the session to identity and cultural diversity

75+ 68 65 63 58 55 53 48 45 43 38-

 

 

 

 

 

Few insights into identity and cultural diversity revealed

Insight into learning content and process demonstrated

75+ 68 65 63 58 55 53 48 45 43 38-

 

 

 

 

 

Little insight into learning content and process

Explicit analysis of the influence of and on personal identity within the session and/or the literature used.

75+ 68 65 63 58 55 53 48 45 43 38-

 

 

 

 

 

 

Few links made with and poor analysis of personal identity issues from the session or within the literature

Analysis of cultural influences within the session and/or within the literature used

75+ 68 65 63 58 55 53 48 45 43 38-

 

 

 

 

 

 

Lack of coherent analysis of cultural influences within the session or the literature

General assessment criteria – excellent

75+ 68 65 63 58 55 53 48 45 43 38-

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

General assessment criteria extremely poor

TOTAL

75+ 68 65 63 58 55 53 48 45 43 38-